Wilson led 50-49 in the final minute of regulation before Penfield's Mitch Cote banked a 3-pointer off glass to take a 52-50 lead with 7.9 seconds remaining. In their final possession, Jevis White hit a runner as time expiered to tie it at 52.
In the extra session, Wilson scored seven of their nine points from the free-throw line. Troy Frierson led the Wildcats with 26 points and 12 rebounds.
With 5.6 seconds remaining and trailing 61-58, Cote tried another buzerr-beater, this time from halfcourt, but it bounced off the rim.
Wilson is now 3-3, Penfield falls to 4-3. The Wildcats will play Brighton on Saturday in the Penfield Coaches Vs Cancer Tournament Final.